1850-1850 Joseph B. Allison
1851-1851 Archibald Campbell
1852-1852 Joseph B. Allison
1853-1853 Archibald Campbell
1854-1854 John P. Dorland
1855-1856 William H. Swetman
1857-1857 Parker Allen
1858-1858 Archibald Campbell
1859-1859 Archibald C. Davis
1860-1860 John P. Dorland
1861-1861 Philip Dorland
1862-1862 William H. Swetman
1863-1864 John J. Watson
1865-1865 John P. Dorland
1866-1866 Archibald C. Davis
1867-1867 John P. Dorland
1868-1870 John J. Watson
1871-1871 Parker Allen
1872-1872 Mortimer C. Bogart
1873-1875 John J. Watson
1876-1877 Peter D. Davis
1878-1879 Henry H. Allison
1880-1881 David D. Allison
1882-1883 Jacob H. Roblin
1884-1884 (Records unavailable)
1885-1886 Nelson Mallory
1886-1886 Jacob H. Roblin
1887-1888 Joseph B. Allison
1889-1889 Jacob H. Roblin
1890-1890 J. W. Dorland
1891-1891 Fred Membery
1892-1892 (Records unavailable)
1893-1895 J. F. Chalmers
1896-1897 T. Nelson David
1898-1898 John Soby
1899-1899 T. Nelson David
1900-1901 C. P. Allen
1902-1902 T. C. Fraser
1903-1904 James Hanlon
1905-1905 T. Nelson David
1906-1906 (Records unavailable)
1907-1907 T. Nelson David
1908-1910 C. F. Allison
1911-1911 Harry M. Johnston
1912-1914 Walter Platt
1915-1917 William D. Roblin
1917-1919 Mark P. Trumpour
1920-1920 C. F. Allison
1921-1930 Jess Johnston
1931-1932 William D. Roblin
1933-1934 Jess Johnston
1935-1937 Jack W. Duffett
1938-1938 J. Roy Johnston
1939-1942 Jack W. Duffett
1943-1954 J. Roy Johnston
1955-1957 Roland Stalker
1957-1962 Joseph Shelley
1963-1965 Gordon Mack
1966-1978 Joseph Shelley
1978-1990 Harold Allison
1991-1993 W. B. Lawson Staples
1994-1996 Carl Clayton
1997-1997 Ed Rae
1998-1998 (Amalgamation with North Fredericksburg, South Fredericksburg, and Napanee to form Town of Greater Napanee)