1838-1838 Thomas Kirkpatrick
1839-1839 Henry Cassady
1839-1840 James Sampson
1841-1843 John Counter
1844-1844 John Sampson
1844-1845 Thomas Sampson
1846-1846 Robert McLean
City Mayors
1846-1846 John Counter
1847-1847 Thomas Kirkpatrick
1848-1848 William Ford, Jr.
1849-1849 Francis Manning Hill
1850-1850 John Counter
1851-1851 Francis Manning Hill
1852-1853 John Counter
1854-1854 John Flanigan
1855-1855 John Counter
1855-1856 Overton Smith Gildersleeve
1857-1857 George Davidson
1858-1858 John Flanigan
1859-1860 Orlanda Simpson Strange
1861-1862 ????
1863-1865 John Creighton
1866-1868 John Breden
1869-1870 William Robinson
1871-1871 Archibald Livingston
1872-1872 Samuel T. Drennan
1873-1873 Henry Cunningham
1874-1875 Michael Sullivan
1876-1876 Byron Moffatt Britton, Q.C.
1877-1877 John McKelvey
1878-1878 John McIntyre, Q.C
1879-1879 Charles F. Gildersleeve
1880-1880 Robert Carson
1881-1881 Edward James Baker Pense
1882-1882 Captain John Gaskin
1883-1883 Charles Livingston
1884-1884 Dr. James McCammon
1885-1885 Edward H. Smythe
1886-1886 John L. Whiting
1887-1887 John Carson
1888-1889 James D. Thompson
1890-1891 William Meville Drennan
1892-1892 Donald M. McIntyre
1893-1893 Neil C. Polson
1894-1894 Dr. John Herald
1895-1895 Clarke W. Wright
1896-1896 Robert Elliott
1897-1897 John S. Skinner
1898-1898 Charles Livingston
1899-1899 Dr. Edward Ryan
1900-1900 James Arnott Minnes
1901-1901 Robert E. Kent
1902-1902 John Morgan Shaw
1903-1904 Dr. John Howatt Bell
1905-1905 Robert N. F. McFarlane
1906-1907 John McDonald Mowatt
1908-1908 Dr. Arthur E. Ross
1909-1910 Daniel Couper
1911-1911 Christopher J. Graham
1912-1912 Franklin John Hoag
1913-1913 Timothy John Rigney
1914-1914 Abraham Shaw
1915-1915 Robert D. Sutherland
1916-1916 A.W. Richardson
1917-1918 John McKane Hughes
1919-1919 Henry Wallace Newman
1920-1921 Hugh Collamer Nickle
1922-1922 Samuel Stewart Corbett
1923-1926 Thomas B. Angrove
1927-1927 Havelock Ford Price
1928-1930 William H. Craig
1931-1932 George Clarke Wright
1933-1933 Dr. Bruce Holmes Hopkins
1934-1934 William P. Peters
1935-1935 J. Clifford Reynolds
1936-1936 George Hanson
1937-1937 Charles P. Dalton
1938-1943 Dr. Harry A. Stewart
1944-1945 C. Leroy Boyd
1946-1947 J. Stuart Crawford
1948-1952 Clifford Austin Curtis
1953-1956 George Clark Wright
1956-1956 Russell E. McCullough
1957-1958 Frank B. Boyce
1959-1964 William T. Mills
1965-1968 Robert A. Fray
1969-1972 E. Valorie Swain
1973-1976 George N. Speal
1977-1980 Kenneth Keyes
1980-1988 John Gerretsen
1988-1993 Helen Cooper
1993-1994 Ken Matthews
1994-2000 Gary H. Bennett
2000-2003 Isabel Turner
2003 now Harvey Rosen